The Golden Compass and Catholicism

Dear Friends in Christ,

It is the duty of the pastor to protect his flock from any dangers that threaten. It is in that spirit that I write to you about the recently released movie, The Golden Compass. The promoters of this movie are marketing it as a children’s film and have cleverly chosen the Christmas season for its release because it is based on a trilogy of “children’s” novels by Philip Pullman, a professed atheist from England. While the movie appears to promote ethical values, it openly ridicules Christianity. Many Catholic and other Christian organizations have come out against this movie because it opposes all organized religion.

The hope of the producers is that people will see the movie and then buy the three book series for children as Christmas gifts. Even atheist societies are somewhat critical of the movie because it doesn’t go as far as the book does in bashing Christians. That is what makes this so dangerous. The movie is a wolf-in-sheep’s clothing because it clothes its anti-religious message as a children’s fantasy tale. You may think that this is just another children’s movie like the Chronicles of Narnia, but Phillip Pullman has gone on record that he dislikes C.S. Lewis. Not only that, he openly states that his purpose in writing the trilogy “His Dark Materials” is to kill the idea of God in the minds of children. We can only hope that the mixed reviews the movie has already received will be enough to limit its audience.

You who are parents should read the reviews of this movie. A very informative website is www.snopes.com. It is not Catholic or Christian, but it simply an informative website that investigates urban legends to find out whether they’re true or not. They have extensive information on The Golden Compass. Philip Pullman’s claim that all organized religion is evil is not fair. While everyone would admit that organized religion includes individuals who commit terrible crimes, we are not thereby permitted to conclude that organized religion is itself evil. That our Church has had its share of first class sinners is proven by history (and even by contemporary events). However, the presence of sinners in the Church is not a proof of her illegitimacy as a divine institution. Even St. Paul admitted that he was a sinner, and so are we all. The Church’s legitimacy (and the legitimacy of Christianity as a whole) is derived from the holiness of her divine Founder, our Lord Jesus Christ. He came to this earth and was born to save man kind from sin. That some choose to reject His way and follow the path of evil is a sign of their free will. God does not force anyone to love Him. He wants us to make that choice freely.

Pullman’s writing shows that he does not understand the constitution of the Church. He makes a caricature of the Church and sets that up as the evil force that crushes people’s freedom. But his sense of absolute freedom from moral norms sounds like the freedom St. Peter warns against when he says, “Be free, yet without using freedom as a pretext for evil” (I Peter 2, 16).

Happy Advent,

Fr. Hildebrand